Memories rewritten and hearts at stake, she must untangle which of two stories — and which love — is the real one.
- Score
- 77.8
- Spice
- 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️Sweet
- POV
- first
- Ending
- HEA / HFN
Tropes
Content warnings
Curated signals, not an exhaustive guarantee.
If you liked this, read
What readers think
Readers who fell for Jacks in the earlier books find the finale deeply satisfying — his tortured devotion to Evangeline, the 'he loves her' emotional payoff, and the resolution of his ancient curse are widely cited as highlights, with many calling him one of the best-written villain love interests in YA romantasy. Garber's lush, lyrical prose and the immersive atmosphere of the Magnificent North continue to earn strong praise. The most consistent criticism targets pacing: roughly sixty percent of the book is slow and repetitive, largely because Evangeline's amnesia resets the romantic tension and strips her of agency for much of the narrative, which frustrates readers who found her naïve in earlier books. A secondary complaint is the volume of Apollo POV chapters, which many felt distracted from the Evangeline–Jacks relationship. The ending is seen as conclusive but somewhat rushed, with several plot threads and world-building elements left under-explored.
Read it if
- · Readers already invested in Jacks and Evangeline who want a cathartic, emotionally wrecking conclusion to their cursed love story
- · Fans of atmospheric YA romantasy with fairy-tale aesthetics, lyrical prose, and morally grey immortal love interests
- · Readers who enjoy swoony, tension-drenched romance where the emotional payoff is earned slowly across an entire trilogy
Skip it if
- · You found Evangeline too passive or naive in the earlier books — her amnesia makes her even more easily manipulated for much of this finale
- · You want a fast-paced, plot-driven conclusion — the middle section drags significantly before the climax arrives
- · You dislike memory-loss/amnesia tropes, as they drive the central conflict for most of the book
If you liked this
- · For fans of Once Upon a Broken Heart and The Ballad of Never After by Stephanie Garber — a direct, essential continuation of the same world and characters
- · For fans of Caraval by Stephanie Garber — the same dreamy, enchanted prose style with a trickster antihero and fairy-tale-soaked atmosphere
- · For fans of The Cruel Prince by Holly Black — a morally grey supernatural love interest, dangerous court politics, and slow-burn forbidden attraction
- · For fans of Sorcery of Thorns by Margaret Rogerson — gothic magic, a heroine who fights with heart rather than weapons, and a beautifully resolved enemies-to-lovers arc
In this series
Part of Once Upon a Broken Heart — read in order:
Full series profile & spice/trope breakdown →Which dark romantasy heroine are you? Five choices in a forest that wants you dead.
Take the quiz →